Monday, 20 May 2013

What makes a text a review? Concering The Great Gatsby

Elements of content

- brief description of (parts of) the plot; unless the author assumes that the audience is familiar with it already

- discussion of the choices the director made. E.g: casting of the actors; Baz Luhrmann's choice of music. "Mixing in a little Jay-Z amid Jazz Age standards strangely makes sense." Comment on subdued ending being not heartwrenching.

- acting: "Maguire always does a fine job when required to look cute and confused".

- discussion of visuals, design

- comparison with director's previous work

Depending on both the reviewer and the film being reviewed, the emphasis on these elements may differ.

Style

- adjectives that express opinion (negative or positive): "a glib and shallow film", "expensive, obsessive, shiny and hollow", "energetic", "weepy", "bombastic"